Monday, June 9, 2014

Becoming Jane ~ A Review


   I've been contemplating writing a review of this movie for quite some time, since it used to be one of my favorite period dramas ever and I have very strong sentiments on it. Since I first saw it, I've learned that it's not actually very accurate and I don't like it now as much as I once did, but I still have very fond memories and feelings toward it. This review might be a bit more gushy and disoriented than my past reviews, since I am very nostalgic and emotional about this movie. But, if you're like me, you like those kinds of reviews best. :-) There will also be lots of pictures and gifs, because I am very fangirly.

  You've been warned.

  So, since it is my custom to begin movie reviews with a story, here is the story of Becoming Jane. ;-D

    Once upon a time, there was a twelve-year-old little girl named Emma. Emma loved reading and writing and pretty much everything old-fashioned, and she was at a time in her life that she would later look back on as her 'awakening'. She had just discovered how much she loved historical fiction and was reading her first Lynn Austin book, and she was also beginning to discover that there were more period dramas out there besides Anne of Green Gables and Little Women. One day she went to the video rental place (I was going to say 'store', but it's not really a store, so I'll just keep it generic and say place ;-P) and amid all the trashy movies that lined the shelves, one particular cover caught her her eye. On the cover was Anne Hathaway, and some terribly handsome youngster with her, and it said it was a movie about Jane Austen. Emma didn't know very much about Jane Austen-- she had heard the name, of course (she didn't live under a rock), and she knew that Jane Austen had lived in the early nineteenth century and written novels, but she really had no knowledge beyond that. Then she remembered that her parents had gone to see a movie a few years earlier about an author by the same name (guess what, they're one and the same!) and when she asked her mama about it, wallah! It was the same movie! So Emma happily picked the movie off the shelf, realized to her disappointment that she had to take one of the copies without the pretty cover, and took it home. And watched it.

   Emma didn't love it at first. At first she thought it was boring, but after she finished it, she kept thinking about it and pondering it and pretty soon came to the conclusion that it was a purty good movie. Then after a while she watched it again, and that settled it. It was her all-time favorite film. :-)
  She decided that she wanted to be just like Jane Austen and write novels, and play the piano early in the morning, and fall in love with an Irish boy like Tom Lefroy. (But of course, he wouldn't ask her to elope.) Young as she was, she didn't realize what an absolute jerk Tom Lefroy is, and she quickly dubbed James McAvoy her favorite actor. And of course Anne Hathaway was her favorite actress, so basically this movie just couldn't get more awesome.

  Alright, now I'm going to stop talking about myself in third-person. :-P
  Becoming Jane was my favorite movie for a long time-- that is, a few years. Then I discovered the internet and read on several period drama-themed blogs about how inaccurate it was, and that knowledge, coupled with the fact that I had found so many period dramas that were even better, began to lower it in my estimation. And while I still love it, it's not my favorite. It's not really even among my top favorites anymore, but I still love it dearly and will always have fond feelings for it. ;-)
 I am going to risk ridicule and censure (and the possible loss of readers, but hopefully not!) by saying that I think Anne Hathaway did do a fairly good job of playing Jane Austen. No, a very good job. She's exactly how I've always imagined her looking when she was young, for one thing. No, she wasn't perfect-- she was a little too melodramatic and flighty (or maybe that was just the way the character was written) and her accent was a little lame. But in a nutshell, I thought her performance was terrific. Anne Hathaway has always been one of my favorites (I say 'always', meaning ever since I was a wee thing and saw her in The Princess Diaries and thought it was so cool that someone else's hair was as crazy as mine-- but then she went and changed it-- um, where was I?), but it was Becoming Jane that really won me over. Say what you like, readers, but I think she's fabulous as Jane Austen. And yes, I'm open to debate-- the comment box is open. *winky-wink*

   Plus, she's absolutely gorgeous, and I like to imagine that Jane Austen looked just like this. She's not pretty in a conventional regency-ish way, either, and her face is actually very unique. I've been told that our expressions are similar, which I take as high praise. ;-)
    Now let's talk about Tom Lefroy.

   One word that aptly describes Tom's character is rascal. He's a mischievous rabble-rouser with loose morals and not a whole lot of conscience, and yet, somehow he's still likeable. At least, I can't help but like him. (What is it with me and Irish men named Tom? :-P) Even though he is a rascal, I maintain that Tom Lefroy does have some decency, and his casual, happy-go-lucky outlook on life does change considerably during the course of the story. He's not your ideal hero, and he's not really anyone to draw an example from. For a while he's not serious about anything, and he goes around beating people up and kissing random girls in the middle of the streets. But other times he can be a gentleman, and a very charming one too. Also, James McAvoy is very handsome.
I love this. :-)
   However, the character portrayal of Tom Lefroy is another case of the screenwriters deviating from the facts. In real life, Jane Austen's suitor Tom Lefroy was a well-behaved young man who wanted to be a clergyman, and who was said to have"everything in his temper and character that can conciliate affections. A good heart , a good mind, good sense and as little to correcting him as ever I saw in one of his age" by his great-uncle. Okay. That is NOT the Tom Lefroy that James McAvoy depicts. I suppose they thought it would be more dramatic and romantic if the character was naughtier and edgier (and the hopeless romantic in me has to agree with them-- it IS more dramatic), but it turns the whole story around. As I have said many times, I love this movie, but I don't think it's a fair interpretation of Jane Austen's relationship with Mr. Lefroy. It's very improvised and glamorized and while I personally don't mind it a whole lot, I understand why lots of Jane Austen admirers do.
I really couldn't resist. ;-P
   I really don't know a whole lot about the real Tom Lefroy, but Miss Laurie has written an excellent post about him that you can read right here.
"What is she trying to say?"

   Jane's sister Cassandra is a sweetheart. Anna Maxwell Martin is such a lovely actress, and she always seems to play lovely characters. Cassandra is one of my favorite characters in the movie, and I think her relationship with Jane is very sweet. It's so tragic when *SPOILER* her fiancé Robert dies *END OF SPOILER*, but I love the scene when Jane and her mother are comforting her, and the scene where Cassandra wakes up and Jane's writing, and Cassandra asks her what it's about.

  "How does it begin?"
  "And then?"
  "Gets worse."
  "And how does it end?"
  "They both make triumphant happy endings."
  "Brilliant marriages?"
  "Incandescent marriages. To very rich men."

   Jane Austen had many siblings (although I can't remember exactly how many), but the only ones shown very much are Cassandra and her younger brother Henry. I know she had an older brother Edward, who Cassandra goes to stay with for a while, although he's never actually shown. There's also George, but I still can't figure out if he's actually her brother or if he's just a neighbor. Jane Austen did have a mentally challenged younger brother, though, so maybe that's him.

      Henry's hair is so annoying that it's enough to make me dislike the character altogether. Of course, I don't really like him very much in the first place. He's a rascal, a flirt, and he doesn't seem to take anything seriously. Also, I think it's kind of strange that he marries his cousin who is obviously close to ten years older than he is. Now, to me, that's just weird. I'm not too terribly fond of Eliza either. She's also a flirt, and it just seems strange to me that she's interested in her young cousin. 

    This is not one of Maggie Smith's best roles. (Well, duh, because we all know what her best role is! *wink, wink*) She's plays her part well, but it's nothing earth-shattering. Lady Gresham is just not nice at all. Her manners are sorely lacking and she has basically no redeeming qualities. And that hooded cape thing she wears is a monstrosity. I'm certain the Dowager Countess would not approve.

   Mr. Wisley, however, is very nice. He's dull as paint and acts like he's made of wood, so his kindness is pretty much the only thing he's got going for himself. I couldn't like him enough to want Jane to marry him-- and besides, she didn't love him, duh-- but I was glad that they became friends in the end.

   Mrs. Austen isn't very nice either, and like her illustrious neighbor, she doesn't really have any redeeming qualities. Mrs. Austen is obviously the inspiration behind Mrs. Bennett, although she is less hysterical and more just plain mean. All she seems to care about is money, and she doesn't give a thought to Jane's happiness, or anyone else's, really; her biggest goal is financial security. The only times I like Mrs. Austen are when *SPOILER* she's comforting Cassandra after her fiancé dies *END OF SPOILER* and when Jane comes back home after leaving with Tom and her mother says, "You came back to us." (*sniffle* That scene always makes me cry. Actually by that time I'm usually sobbing anyway.) And I like it when Mrs. Austen defends Jane's reputation to Lady Grouchy. So she isn't all bad, and like most people in the movie, she seems like a better person and a more affectionate mother by the end.

   Farmer Hoggett Reverend Austen is a very kind man and a loving father, but he's not my favorite either. He's nice and all, he's just a little....dull. He does seem to care about Jane's future happiness more than his wife, but he also encourages her to marry Mr. Wisley, saying it is "likely to be her best offer." I do like him-- he just doesn't impress me a whole lot.

Look at his hair. Bwahahaha.

  Let's see, other characters.....there's Tom's uncle, the judge (who must have a name somewhere, but I can't seem to remember it right now), who is just plain IRRITATING. I think it's rather funny how Ian Richardson always seems to play judges-- he must like to, because I think I've seen him play a judge in at least three movies. Tom's uncle is not a very nice man and he makes no secret of his disapproval of Tom's character. He is training Tom to become a lawyer (btw, the way James McAvoy says 'lawyer' and 'law' is really some form of art), and when he finds out that Tom wants to marry Jane he threatens to disinherit him. I really don't like him. The end.

 There are several other secondary characters, but they're not that important so I'm not going to take the time to mention them.

  The costumes in this movie have some serious issues. Some of them are lovely, especially Jane's, but most of them are sadly inaccurate. For instance, why is Jane the only one wearing a Regency dress, and everyone else is dressed Georgian?

And what is this?????
I lurve this coat. ;-)
   Many of the costumes are beautiful, though, and Jane's wardrobe is one of my very favorites. I especially love her pink and white gown that she wears to the Basingstroke assembly when she dances with Tom, her cream-colored ball gown, her green and brown dress, and the brown dress she wears when she comes back from London. She also has several gorgeous blue dresses. Actually, considering the fact that the Austens were not well-to-do, Jane may have just a few too many dresses for it to be accurate....but we'll let that slide 'cause they're just all so purty.

    The men's costumes are quite nice indeed. :-) Especially Tom Lefroy's, which is only to be expected. His wardrobe is very fashionable and reflects his extravagant, spend-all personality. Also he seems to wear a lot of green-- random observation.
Should I apologize for using so many gifs? No, I think not.

   Besides the glaring inaccuracy of some of the costumes, most everything else in the movie seems relatively on par with the period, although Jane's posture could use a bit of work. The ladies always wear their hair up, so that's an improvement from P&P. ;-D The dialogue is pretty historical, but sometimes I think they added just a few too many adjectives in their attempt to make it fitting for the period-- in the scene where Jane and Tom meet in the woods, Jane seems to have swallowed a dictionary, as Mrs. Patmore would say. Also there is a distinct overuse of the word 'vastly'-- it seems to be everyone's favorite word. Especially in the scene where Jane is reading to her family and Tom first arrives; I think they use it about four times. Vastly this, vastly that. "Green velvet coat-- vastly fashionable."
   The ball scene at Lady Gresham's is one of my very favorites. First of all, the music is hauntingly gorgeous, the costumes are scrumptious, and I love love LOVE this dance. Possibly my favorite part in the whole movie is when Jane starts dancing with Mr. Wisley, and then suddenly Tom is there dancing with her, wearing that adorable smirk of his. It's soooooooo romantic. :-)
   Speaking of romantic....
   Anne Hathaway and James McAvoy are just so epic together. Jane and Tom are one of the most romantic doomed couples I've ever seen. Normally doomed couples get on my nerves (like Rose and Jack in Titanic...cough, cough), but Jane and Tom don't. I'm not saying there's nothing melodramatic about their relationship; quite the contrary, it's VERY melodramatic. But not in a way that it's annoying-- I want them to be able to be together and live happily ever after, and yet it's not such a terrible disappointment when they don't. I'm probably not making a lick of sense, am I? Well, suffice to say that I love these two, 'kay?

   This movie doesn't have a happy ending. Why are we not surprised. ;-P As most of us know, Jane Austen never marries, and Tom goes back to Ireland, marries someone else, and becomes a very prominent attorney. (And he names his eldest daughter Jane. SOB.) But even though Jane and Tom don't end up together and the ending is tragic, it's also beautiful. I love the way it ends with Jane reading Pride and Prejudice, and then everyone claps, and THEY LOOK AT EACH OTHER and time stands still and the universe stops.....
   Also I think they did a real good job of making the actors look old without making them look artificial. Actually I think James McAvoy almost looks more handsome with gray hair and sideburns. ;-P

   As far as content (a word which here means anything inappropriate), there really isn't much to worry about in Becoming Jane. There is some language, but nothing shocking and it's not very frequent-- just the usual of what is to be expected in movies about this period. There's also one brief scene where Tom and Henry go swimming, but that can easily be avoided by turning one's head away, and it's pretty easy to see coming.
 The soundtrack of Becoming Jane is simply gorgeous. It used to be one of my favorite soundtracks, and I still love listening to it. The music is composed by Adrian Johnston, the same composer who did the music to Our Mutual Friend (1998). Here's one of my favorite tracks, called 'A Last Reading'.

   There are so many gorgeous trailers for this movie, so here's one of them:

   So this isn't the best period drama I've ever seen, and if you're looking for an accurate depiction of Jane Austen's young life, you'll probably be disappointed. But it's a beautiful movie and a very romantic story, with excellent acting and gorgeous music, and I'm very fond of it. :-)
"Will all your stories have happy endings?"
"My characters will have, after a little bit of trouble, all that they desire."




  1. Oh my goodness I do love your reviews. Your reviews are long, plain-interesting, fun to read and not just 'reviews' like mine are.

    Emma sweety, I didn't know you liked this movie so much! Why not you tell me you cheeky little- well I won't say 'thing' because I think it sounds mean.

    Well, I'll just tell you, I don't like this movie very much. But I don't dislike it either. It was worse than I had imagined and it annoys me to death that almost everything is fictional but the names but it was enjoyable.

    "Alright, now I'm going to stop talking about myself in third-person."

    Why did you? I was just enjoying it so much. :-P

    Jane was good. I thought Anne Hathaway did a good job. I had, for some reason (and still do) always imagined Jane Austen as a shy woman who always creapt up to write. But she wasn't- she was very social, so I suppose Anne Hathaway was really good. And I think she really looks like Jane.

    Who told you that your expressions were similar? I'm curious now. :-P

    Okay. I'm going to say it. I really did not like Tom Lefroy. I feel like saying that I simply hate him. 'ate 'im. I wish I DID eat him. That was a joke Emma. Laugh.
    He was- as you explained so perfectly- a rascal. A flirt and a rambunctious buffoon. Sorry.

    But he was handsome. I cannot defend myself upon THAT matter.

    But no. I hated him. What does he think! Swimming naked in a public pool! Gliding off banisters!!! (That was supposed to be shocking Emma, you shouldn't love it)

    Besides, I didn't think he was good at acting a hero. Sorry darling. I didn't like James McAvoy. And never will I.

    Besides it bugs me SOOOO much that they made him like that, 'cos Jane Austen would NEVEVEVEVEVEVEVEVEVER have gone off with such a stupid fella. Jane Austen is a sensible lovely and mature woman, come on!

    Oh yes! I love Jane and Cassnadra together!!! Pity they don't look AT ALL like sisters.

    Jane Austen was part of a family with nine children, like your bosom friend dear. I'm jolly glad I don't have seven brothers. :-)

    Mrs Austen was awful. Even worse than Mrs Bennet!

    THE COSTUMES. Argh. Jane's were pretty (but NOT THAT RED ONE I AGREE) but why is everyone dressed in Georgian!!!! Same in P&P you know! Jane is the only on in good clothing there as well. It drives me CRAAAAAAAAAZY.



    I'm going to cut and past one of your sentances:
    "Besides the glaring inaccuracy of some of the costumes, most everything else in the movie seems relatively on par with the period, although Jane's posture could use a bit of work. The ladies always wear their hair up, so that's an improvement from P&P. ;-D"
    You wrote that for me.
    Say that you wrote that for me.

    Well you forgot the sliding on the stairs thingy. And the candle kiss. Again, I don't think Jane would have gone in a dark garden and kiss a boxer who kisses everyone. No- it's not very historically accurate and certainly not accurate her real life. Brrrr.
    But it's better than P&P05. Yes.

    I love that word, vastly. I love it vastly!

    Yes. I'll admit it. I loved that dancing scene. Although I don't like his smile. It looks creepy and menacing. Sorry.

    Yes I agree with you. However much I dislike Tom, I did want them to marry. However much I thought 'Why on earth does Jane want him' I did want her to be happy.

    I love it when she writes because I always recognise P&P or S&S. I LURVE IT. I'd watch it again just for that. And I love it when she reads it at the end.

    But I don't like it that they look at each-other. She can look at him yes, she has loyally stayed un-married. But he! He's married for goodness sake and has children!! Sorry.

    Well, I clearly am more of an Austen-fan than you are :) I just WANT everything to be accurate!!!

    But nevertheless I enjoyed this review A VAST deal. You are SUCH a good writer dear.
    Sorry for my criticism and for probably making you upset. But we're best friends and we tell each-other the truth, 'kay?

    And I shall NEVER stop being your reader.


  3. Thanks for the review! This movie does look interesting because I like Anne Hathaway, but it seems like for a life of Jane Austen, they pushed the romance a bit too much! I read a book on her, and the romance wasn't a big part of her life. But, I can see how it would make a good movie :) Oh, and there is no such thing as too many GIFs :D

  4. Alice dear,

    No, no, no! Your criticism doesn't upset me at all! Quite the contrary, I love it. In fact, it makes me feel almost guilty for liking this movie, because you're absolutely right.

    Why haven't I told you before that I liked this movie so much? I don't know. Probably because I don't really like it that much now-- I used to be crazy about it, but now the main reason why I like it is because I have such fond memories of loving it when I was younger.

    Yes, I know, almost everything is fictional except the names. I know most of it is revisionist nonsense, and it's glamorized a lot to make it more romantic. I don't blame you one bit for disliking it. But just indulge me. :-P

    Good. You think Anne Hathaway was good as Jane-- I do too. I'm glad we agree on that. :-)

    I don't blame you for hating Tom Lefroy either. (Well, OF COURSE I don't blame you. Everyone is entitled to their own opinions, and in this case YOUR views on the subject are obviously the more sensible. ;-P) you not like James McAvoy in general, or do you just hate Tom Lefroy? Because you really shouldn't judge him because of that-- he's really a fantastic actor and one of my favorites.

    No no no, Jane Austen would never have gone off with him. You're absolutely right. I really don't know how much of the movie is made up and how much is actually true, but I'm pretty sure any respectable young lady would NEVER consider eloping with a man her family disapproved of and who had just been disinherited by his rich uncle. That part just screams of improvisation.

    Yeah I know, Jane and Cassandra look absolutely nothing alike. But I thought they were very sweet as sisters. (You HAVE to see Bleak House, darling. Anna Maxwell Martin is brilliant.) Btw, Sadie is the one who first said I looked like Anne Hathaway. My cousin also said my expressions sometimes look like her. I can do a pretty good job of imitating her, if I do say so myself. (You should hear my take on her version of I Dreamed a Dream.) ;-P

    Okay, I guess the sliding-down-the-banister thing is shocking, but I still love it. Sorry. :-P And the candle kiss. And the kiss by the pond in the rose garden. OKAY. Although I must admit, I love the scene in the rose garden. However historically improper, it's soooo lovely. I know you are probably shaking your head at me.

    Oh! I don't think James McAvoy's smile is menacing! Not at all! I think it's charming and adorable.

    Yeah, I always thought Tom must be so embarrassed to see her again when he's married and had children, because here she is, still unmarried. It's almost like he's forgotten her. You're right, it's awkward. But I still like it when they look at each other. It's just so meaningful.

    Yes, you are definitely more of an Austen fan than I am. Indubitably. If it were something I had stronger feelings about, I would want everything to be accurate too. So I understand.

    And lastly, I am very glad that you found some amusement in my review. And thanks for telling me what you think-- it means a lot to me that you're always honest with me. We're best friends and we tell each other the truth. :-)


    You're welcome! Glad you enjoyed it! Yes, they definitely did push the romance-- from what I've heard, a lot of this movie is made up. But I still enjoy it, and aside from all the inaccuracy I think it's a very good film. Thanks for your comment! :-)


    P.S. Wow. Long comment.

  5. Emmsker,

    Well I don't know if I like James McAvoy because I've only seen him in Becoming Jane (you know what I think about him then, I shan't repeat it all again:) and in Narnia- you know my views upon that subject too!
    But I'm sure he's good in other roles. :-)

    I'm glad you liked my honest opinion and thought it more sensible than yours :-P

    Oh YES! Do send me a video clip of you singing I dreamed a dream! PLEEEESH.

    Thanks for answering dear!

  6. My mom gave me this movie for my birthday last year, and I still haven't watched it. Because, based on "X-Men: First Class," I thought James McAvoy was a boring actor. (Forgive me.) BUT, based on "X-men: Days of Future Past," I now know he's capable of being interesting, so I intend to watch this sometime this summer :-)


I'd love it if you'd drop me a line or two! I always enjoy receiving comments from readers and friends. I ask that you please keep your comments clean and God-honoring, and please don't write anything you wouldn't want your grandmother to read. Also, if you are commenting under anonymous, please do leave your name (or some sort of moniker so that you aren't totally nameless). Thank you so much and have a lovely day!

Related Posts Plugin for WordPress, Blogger...